Answered in 6 episodes
How do I stop losing and regaining the same 10 pounds?
Answered by Nikkiey Stott and her guests · Updated
The short answer
Stop treating it as a 30-day diet and start building habits, beliefs and skills that outlast the plan. Nikkiey explains that the same 10 pounds keep coming back when old habits return after a diet ends, when you quit before your body responds, and when nobody teaches you how to move from fat loss into maintenance.
Hear it from the show
Tap play to start right where it's answered. It keeps playing while you browse.
Nikkiey on why 30-day diets put you back on the 10-pound hamster wheel
Plays from 6:39 · Ep. 189: Diet vs Lifestyle Change: How to Keep Weight Off After 40
Why a new plan fails if you never change who you are
Plays from 10:08 · Ep. 23: How to Stick to Fitness Habits by Changing Your Identity
Nikkiey on quitting before your body has a chance to respond
Plays from 14:44 · Ep. 26: How to Lose Weight and Keep It Off for Good
How to transition out of fat loss into maintenance without regaining
Plays from 14:23 · Ep. 233: How to Stop Yo-Yo Dieting and Keep the Weight Off
Darci on ending every program heavier than when she started
Plays from 5:36 · Ep. 316: Eating More and Losing Weight After 50: Darci's Story
The full answer
On Ep. 189, Nikkiey describes the usual pattern: you cut out everything to lose 10 pounds in 30 days, then go right back to what you were doing before. That is not a lifestyle change. It is getting on and off the hamster wheel. Diets come with cookie-cutter rules and restrictions you don't enjoy, so you leave them. Her alternative is treating macros as a skill set that serves you for life. On Ep. 316, Darci shares that every program left her heavier, because she had set calorie counts or points with no adjusting, no phases, little emphasis on exercise and no habits to carry on once it ended.
On Ep. 23, Nikkiey goes a layer deeper: people on the wheel have a new goal and a new plan, but they didn't change who they were. The habits that took the 10 pounds off started to shift their beliefs, but that change never fully sank in. In her words, true behavior change is identity change.
On Ep. 26, she points to patience and consistency. Many women give up before their body has a chance to respond, and one week without a scale drop does not mean you aren't making progress. You don't have to be perfect. You need a foundation of small daily systems, like planning your day and drinking your water, followed consistently until they compound.
Finally, have an exit plan. On Ep. 233, Nikkiey says most diets offer no long-term strategy or education on returning to real life. Learn the why and how behind your nutrition, and transition slowly out of fat loss into maintenance so you can eat more without losing progress. Instead of retrying an old diet, ask what you can do differently this time to make results last. On Ep. 368, Debbie lost her first 10 pounds while eating more during her retrain into maintenance.
From The WarriorBabe Show with Nikkiey Stott. For education, not medical advice: talk to your doctor about your own health.
Women also ask
More questions →
Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture
Why don't fad diets work long term?
Fad diets don't work long term because they are built for fast results through extreme restriction, not for real life. Nikkiey explains that when the program ends, the foods you cut out come back, often more than before, and so does the weight. Nothing teaches you how to keep the results afterward.
Read the answer →

Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture
Is keto sustainable long term?
No, not for most women. Nikkiey explains that keto can work if you follow it strictly, but it isn't designed to be sustainable. Almost nobody gives up carbs for the rest of their life, going in and out of ketosis stalls progress, and cutting carbs can make building muscle much harder.
Read the answer →

Diets, Fasting & Diet Culture
Do I need intermittent fasting to lose fat?
No. Nikkiey Stott says intermittent fasting isn't necessary for fat loss. A calorie deficit combined with physical activity and strength training is what drives it. She calls fasting overrated for healthy women, warns that skipping meals often leads to overeating later, and says your muscle needs regular fuel to be built and repaired.
Read the answer →
Watch the full episodes
More episodes →
22 minHow to Lose Weight and Keep It Off for Good
Episode 26 · Mar 8, 2023
28 minDiet vs Lifestyle Change: How to Keep Weight Off After 40
Episode 189 · Sep 13, 2024
25 minHow to Stick to Fitness Habits by Changing Your Identity
Episode 23 · Mar 1, 2023
Free Body Transformation Assessment
Done with diets? Good. So are we.
Keto, fasting, 1,200 calories, Monday restarts. You did the work, and the diets let you down. We'll help you eat in a way you can keep for life.
- No foods off-limits
- Eat more and still see results
- A plan built for the long term
21,800+ women transformed